Chapter 1. Solution Decision Framework

The notion of software architecture has been around for about 50 years; however, only in the 1990s did it become a part of the computer industry dictionary. Since then, it has undergone some evolution, influenced by other areas of software development and project management. In the Software Architecture and Design chapter of the Microsoft Application Architecture Guide, 2nd Edition document (2009), software application architecture is defined as follows:

Today, the notion of software architecture is typically applied to two major areas of the industry: project development and product development. Project development is characterized by the fact that every project has a beginning and an end, which always has a time frame. At the beginning of the project, there is normally a requirements-gathering process, and the solution that is delivered at the end of the project has to satisfy those requirements. Some requirements describe the business functionality of the solution. Other requirements can specify its availability, extensibility, resilience, security, and many other nonfunctional aspects.

In product development, businesses focus on developing products according to the initial set of requirements or upgrading them according to the subsequent sets of requirements. In a typical process, the software development life cycle (SDLC) has several stages. The stages start from generating an idea of the new product, business analysis, and market research about the coding, testing, delivering to the market, and maintenance. Delivering a new version of a software product can be considered a project itself; however, the entire product development process is cyclic typically, and it does not have a visible end. There are many SDLC methodologies from Waterfall to a whole spectrum of Agile ones; the focus of the architect's role in them is very different from one to another.

In this chapter, we'll consider an architect's approach to a typical software project. We'll discuss the need for an architectural decision framework and sources of information that influence an architect's decisions. We'll talk about evaluating technologies and how organizational context, solution design, implementation, as well as operations have their impact on such an evaluation.